I think this needs to be discussed - While the vaults flaky...

[Legacy_Tarot Redhand]

               Tchos can you give upload dates for your examples please? It would be helpful to know how long it took to get those scores.

TR
               
               

               
            

[Legacy_Tchos]

               They were all shortly after the Nexus opened its NWN section this past March...  Let's see what the exact dates were.

Okay. According to the action logs, #1 was uploaded 2012-03-18, #2 was 2012-03-09, and #3 was 2012-03-10.  

As an example of what I think is the high end of downloads, I think the most popular module on the Nexus is Slowdivefan's Icewind Dale NWN2 remake, which has 2159 unique downloads of each of its files (meaning those are different computers downloading it, discarding any duplicate from the same IP), and that was also uploaded right at the Nexus' opening, 2012-03-09.
               
               

               
            

[Legacy_NWN_baba yaga]

               About the download numbers... when I take the downloads seriously into account for my work motivation I can immidiately stop and throw nwn out the window! I have 55 downloads for my ravencast tileset which is a beautifull crafted forest set imo, not big but perfect for what it represents and the only one available since 10 years. So I keep it as I always did and do everything for myself first and then  decide how the content will be shared with the community. I never took the NWN numbers to serious because compared to the massive numbers the ****ty (almost) content producers for DAO and MAE peoples are reaching there is just no justification for it and I´m not gonna fall into a depresive hole cuz I´m not producing for the mass apeal. Whew

By now we all should have accepted that nwn is a small game in numbers and a niche;)

I´m very interested in modding in general and i always lurk in other forums and modsites too and you quickly realize that it´s not always the quality that produces high numbers. Some people just retexture a nightgown mesh into a pink mess but their download numbers reach around 10.000.... numbers are just not related when it comes down to the art of modding.

p.s. I´m sure we can blame bioware or EA for taking down the master server and the old forums that the numbers have decreased so much. YES it´s true!!! ... and NO we cannot:D (change anything about it in my believe)
               
               

               

                     Modifié par NWN_baba yaga, 02 septembre 2012 - 12:11 .
                     
                  

            

[Legacy_kamal_]

               

ShaDoOoW wrote...

OldTimeRadio wrote...

Nexus is an interesting alternative but after going through a sampling of the downloads there I'm getting the feeling that some uploaders are pretending that the Nexus is just like "another" Vault, which it is definitely not.  People uploading content without understanding the Nexus's extremely strict rules on giving credit, plagiarism & copyright infringement should not be surprised if their content comes under a Moderator's fine-tooth-comb review and, if it doesn't pass, is deleted and them unceremoniously banned.  Banning at Nexus is a common occurrence and business, nothing personal.

Hmm from what I read and can see these restrictions seems fine to me. I understand someone would want to restrict his content and some folks are doing it on vault already - the difference is that vault never preserved these people's rights - you maybe remember the issue with diademus now baba_yaga and his content.

The restrictions are visible to anyone, arent they? This makes things easier, or legalized if you want, for projects like CEP which were in past accused of taking content without permissions. Now the situation is that most CC creators are gone from NWN community so asking isnt even possible - not to mention that vault emailing system doesnt work for almost year now.

Shame, that NWN nexus seems dead, some peoples are uploading the content here but it seems there is noone that would downloaded it (other than peoples from these forums). But that might be because less and less peoples have interest in this anymore...

I agree it's a shame not more people download NWN1/2 stuff (I just started playing NWN1 modules again). But I have to disagree with the no one downloading from the Nexus statement. I put up a module (NWN2) on the Nexus I'd released on that Vault in 2010. By the time I put it on the Nexus in March 2012 it had roughly nine thousand downloads at the Vault. The module on the Nexus has a thousand downloads, and my module on the Vault is now at almost ten thousand. So from my experience, I'm getting roughly as many downloads at each source. If anything, I view the Nexus as providing choice for downloaders, and "backup" for times like now when the Vault is unresponsive. In NWN2, the larger file sizes mean the lack of the 25 meg ftp and approval system of the Vault are a godsend.
               
               

               

                     Modifié par kamal_, 02 septembre 2012 - 12:35 .
                     
                  

            

[Legacy_kamal_]

               

OldTimeRadio wrote...

Here you go:
Curse
GameFront
ModDB
Nexus
SpellHold Studios
Strategy Informer

Curse has zero entries for NWN. Spellhold Studios latest NWN1 news is 2008. For options, it seems those are in a status of never begun, and effectively abandoned.
               
               

               
            

[Legacy_kamal_]

               

Master Jax wrote...

I disagree with the nexus thing. The layout looks cheap and it is slow. I've also had lots of trouble trying to make an account. To this day, the thing hasn't been fixed, even after reporting and sending mails to the appropriate individuals. Of course, this is merely personal opinion and situation.

You can message the owner of the Nexus via these forums to get your account fixed. social.bioware.com/34287/ He directly fixed issues for a number of NWN2 people.

There was a long thread on the NWN2 forums about the Nexus here during the Vault's previous silence. The owner of the Nexus worked with the NWN2 community to do things like establish what types of content tags would be best.
social.bioware.com/forum/1/topic/172/index/9196246/1

There was a post on the NWN1 forums at the time about the Nexus as well, but it didn't draw responses. social.bioware.com/forum/1/topic/191/index/9638982
               
               

               
            

[Legacy_Pstemarie]

               I'm starting see that, except for a group of individual people that frequent these forums, that CC for NWN is for the most part dead. Does that mean we need to stop creating content and sharing things certainly not. We just need to come up with a reasonable way to do that.

Personally, I think that a hosting site like the Vault or the Nexus is a bad idea. After looking over the Nexus' TOS more thoroughly I can safely say **** that. That looks like the same BS that nearly broke the Community in the first place. We're a small group - we've got to learn to leave this BS behind us and work together and more importantly to SHARE. If you don't want people breaking your stuff up and putting it in their own compilations then don't post it, don't talk about it here, and save us all a headache. Bottom line is that those of us who are left really don't need or want this BS. Furthermore, most users here are quite capable of duplicating anything they see not to mention improving upon it.

Frankly what wrong with using something like skydrive (25 gig) or dropbox to share files? You can set them to public on skydrive, post a link and anyone that wants to can download the stuff. Plus you also avoid all the trolling and other crap if someone gets ticked at you and decides to purposely run down your project - as what happened with the Community Patch.

The best practice would probably be to get a sticky thread here for project alerts then have authors post link from that. Failing that (cause it hard to get anything stickied here), I'd be more than glad to start a google site that serves as a link database for anyone that's interested.
               
               

               
            

[Legacy_Just a ghost]

               Must say I am not much of a fan of Nexus, but I only speak from the consumer's point of view. With most files you don't even know if you're talking NWN1 or 2. Terrible UI and organisation, if you ask me.
               
               

               
            

[Legacy_Shadooow]

               

kamal_ wrote...

I agree it's a shame not more people download NWN1/2 stuff (I just started playing NWN1 modules again). But I have to disagree with the no one downloading from the Nexus statement. I put up a module (NWN2) on the Nexus I'd released on that Vault in 2010. By the time I put it on the Nexus in March 2012 it had roughly nine thousand downloads at the Vault. The module on the Nexus has a thousand downloads, and my module on the Vault is now at almost ten thousand. So from my experience, I'm getting roughly as many downloads at each source. If anything, I view the Nexus as providing choice for downloaders, and "backup" for times like now when the Vault is unresponsive. In NWN2, the larger file sizes mean the lack of the 25 meg ftp and approval system of the Vault are a godsend.

Well my observation is based on very short time frame since im quite new to nexus, the need to register just to download kept me away for a while.

EDIT: Projects would be great place where to drop files, however is very disappointing that Bioware doesnt improved this feature over years and people's suggestions.

Only 10 files per project is very limited, it is nice that I can upload almost 20GB of content but I would have to zip multiple entries together to avoid the 10items limit. Album feature inside project has never worked for me - was reporting this already, no dev cares. The files extension are also very limited, why isnt there 7zip?

Unability to use html in project description, new lines in files description, comments ordered from oldest so you often miss new comments as that requires you to browse to all "pages", unability to re-upload file on the same spot keeping that file DL count, very limited forum functionality (what annoys me that after deletion the posts arent re-sorted and the message that I deleted the message appears instead).
               
               

               

                     Modifié par ShaDoOoW, 02 septembre 2012 - 02:56 .
                     
                  

            

[Legacy_kamal_]

               

Pstemarie wrote...

Frankly what wrong with using something like skydrive (25 gig) or dropbox to share files? You can set them to public on skydrive, post a link and anyone that wants to can download the stuff. Plus you also avoid all the trolling and other crap if someone gets ticked at you and decides to purposely run down your project - as what happened with the Community Patch.

I've hosted things via Dropbox before. The problem I ran into was that I went over their bandwith cap very quickly (I went over only via the downloads of beta testers of my mod) and they shut down downloads for a month. Now this was my NWN2 mod, and was quite large, so it may not be such a problem for NWN1 mods or CC for either game due to smaller file sizes. Skydrive I do not know what kind of bandwith caps they have, if any.

I agree with ShaDoOoW that the Bioware projects page are just terrible for many reasons.
               
               

               
            

[Legacy_Pstemarie]

               Skydrive has no bandwidth limits. You just can't have more than 25GB worth of files on your account.

I'll also elaborate a bit on my google site idea...

What I'm basically looking at is a site that's divided into two sections - NWN and NWN2. Authors can come, fill out a form drop in a link and description and be done with it. The form is then populated to a list that allows users to view and sort projects. I can set up a demo if you guys want to see what I'm talking about... 
               
               

               

                     Modifié par Pstemarie, 02 septembre 2012 - 04:00 .
                     
                  

            

[Legacy_B_Harrison]

               I'm surprised you guys haven't jumped to the Nexus site!

Any concerns over how content creators' rights are enforced don't seem relevant, as those rules only apply when permission/credit is required and has not been given (if the NWN modding community is tight-knit and small enough now that no one places limitations on the use of their content, it's a non-issue).

Of course I've been out of the loop for quite a while, and might be missing something... and I may be a bit biased, given that I've just released my first public Skyrim mod on the Nexus and, like Six, find the sites pretty familiar.

Surely the user/player angle is significant, as well? Are all/any of the PW players having issues with the Vault?
               
               

               

                     Modifié par B_Harrison, 02 septembre 2012 - 04:57 .
                     
                  

            

[Legacy_Zwerkules]

               

Tchos wrote...

Also, let me throw a few numbers out there as a measure of relative activity.  I have three mods, each of which I released on both the Vault and the Nexus at the same time.  For all three of them, I have far more downloads, votes, and comments on the Nexus versions as I do on the Vault versions.

1. Nexus: 895 downloads, 32 votes, 67 comments, 10078 views
   Vault: 276 downloads, 3 votes, 7 comments, unknown views (not tracked on Vault)

2. Nexus: 500 downloads, 15 votes, 27 comments, 6357 views
   Vault: 167 downloads, 4 votes, 4 comments, unknown views

3. Nexus: 104 downloads, 4 votes, 2 comments, 1228 views
   Vault: 75 downloads, 0 votes, 0 comments, unknown views

Naturally, I'll continue to upload my new material to both places, as long as they exist.

I stopped using the nexus because my experience with it was exactly the opposite from yours.
Did you upload files for NWN1 or 2? I guess NWN2. About the only haks for NWN1 that get any amount of downloads or even a comment are nude haks and the like.

Medieval City tileset:

Nexus: 17 downloads, no comments
Vault: more than 1000 downloads, 68 comments and 35 votes

I never had any major problems with the vault and will continue to use it.
               
               

               

                     Modifié par Zwerkules, 02 septembre 2012 - 06:11 .
                     
                  

            

[Legacy_kamal_]

               

Zwerkules wrote...

Tchos wrote...

Also, let me throw a few numbers out there as a measure of relative activity.  I have three mods, each of which I released on both the Vault and the Nexus at the same time.  For all three of them, I have far more downloads, votes, and comments on the Nexus versions as I do on the Vault versions.

1. Nexus: 895 downloads, 32 votes, 67 comments, 10078 views
   Vault: 276 downloads, 3 votes, 7 comments, unknown views (not tracked on Vault)

2. Nexus: 500 downloads, 15 votes, 27 comments, 6357 views
   Vault: 167 downloads, 4 votes, 4 comments, unknown views

3. Nexus: 104 downloads, 4 votes, 2 comments, 1228 views
   Vault: 75 downloads, 0 votes, 0 comments, unknown views

Naturally, I'll continue to upload my new material to both places, as long as they exist.

I stopped using the nexus because my experience with it was exactly the opposite from yours.
Did you upload files for NWN1 or 2? I guess NWN2. About the only haks for NWN1 that get any amount of downloads or even a comment are nude haks and the like.

Medieval City tileset:

Nexus: 17 downloads, no comments
Vault: more than 1000 downloads, 68 comments and 35 votes

I never had any major problems with the vault and will continue to use it.

This isn't about abandoning the Vault, but about having an accepted alternative/secondary site in case the Vault has problems/disappears. The Vault had a month long period of no publication of submissions, with no news as to why. It's currently going on 2 1/2 weeks since the last publication of submissions, and Rolo isn't around to handle submits. If the Vault isn't publishing, there needs to be another way to get stuff out.
               
               

               
            

[Legacy_NWN_baba yaga]

               I never thought it´s about abandoning the vault rather then having other sources to share content and if it helps nwn to keep some attention going on hey, it´s free for us to use it;)