No, I like Carth, I just think he's a massive wuss for saying he'll protect us then backing out the first time we need him to
'> And Dead ex is different than dead family, even if his son survived
But then again, I was always a little put out that I couldn't have my Revan totally freak out and have an identity crisis. You think about it, very few people are going to handle the fact that their entire life is a lie well...
I guess I mainly object to the fact that the dead ex thing has become cliched, and as a result few people can write it in a way that isn't tedious. I understand we may not of been the first love interest in the companion's life, but GEEZ! Does the ex need to die every time? Is it impossible for people to just break up in video games? I understand having your girlfriend leave you because you refuse to help with the housework isn't as dramatic as being murdered by space pirates, but at least it's relatable.